| 2013 | Salt Lake Bees (T17) | New York Yankees (T20) | View Season |
| 2014 | Houston Astros (T15) | Anaheim Angels (T13) | View Season |
| 2015 | Houston Astros (T15) | Saint Louis Cardinals (T17) | View Season |
| 2016 | Houston Astros (T15) | Chicago Cubs (T08) | View Season |
| 2017 | Saint Louis Cardinals (T17) | Kansas City Royals (T03) | View Season |
| 2018 | Saint Louis Cardinals (T17) | New York Mets (T20) | View Season |
| 2019 | Cincinnati Reds (T06) | Saint Louis Cardinals (T17) | View Season |
| 2020 | Montreal Expos (T10) | Chicago Cubs (T08) | View Season |
| 2021 | Saint Louis Cardinals (T17) | Montreal Expos (T10) | View Season |
| 2022 | Los Angeles Dodgers (T12) | Saint Louis Cardinals (T17) | View Season |
| 2023 | Washington Senators (T03) | Saint Louis Cardinals (T17) | View Season |
| 2024 | Saint Louis Cardinals (T17) | Chicago Cubs (T08) | View Season |
| 2025 | Saint Louis Cardinals (T17) | Cincinnati Reds (T06) | View Season |